Jump to content
Lord_Chris

Official Download Central Review Guidelines

Recommended Posts

Official Download Central Review Guidelines

 

The following rules and regulations will come into place once you post, comment or review in our Download Central. By doing so, it is assumed you have agreed with these guidelines.

 

Firstly, self-reviews are not allowed. Any such reviews will be removed by a downloads moderator. Because it is impossible for us to keep everything perfect on our site, we would ask that if users find any content that is malicious, abusive, or otherwise inappropriate they report it using the report_file.gif icon at the end of a comment, review or file. Our moderators will then check this out and if found true, the file/comment will be disabled, or in some cases, but not necessarily, removed.

 

Why review or comment on a file?

 

This will allow the user to receive other opinions on their work, other opinions they may never have thought of. Reviewing people's files will give them a chance to better improve their work, and to not make the same mistakes again. No extreme criticism of people's work is allowed. Any such posts may be removed. Be civil at all times, everything you get is voluntary, please remember that. Any file authors who get abusive will have the applicable files closed. This means no more comments or reviews can be added. You never know, the same person may be around to review your own work!

 

Scores

 

The scores range from 5 to 1. 5 is the highest, and while it is nice to give everyone 5's, it isn't always appropriate. That doesn't mean be too harsh either, try and be fair. The different areas you give a score for are:

 

Written Description, Playability, Landscape, Creativity. An average of these values (mean) will give the overall rating. You can edit the text of a review, but not even a downloads moderator can edit the ratings of a review.

 

Written Description

 

We understand that not everybody likes writing, and that not everybody reads a complete written description when downloading. For that reason, feel free to give whatever you feel is appropriate for this for whatever reason. I.E. Mark for how interesting, how much you enjoyed it or even just how helpful you generally found it.

 

Playability

 

How playable the map was; or, in other words, how good it was to play it, how many times do you think you could play it again and get different results or do different things, did you enjoy playing it, did it keep you hooked?

 

Landscape

 

How good or detailed was the landscape? Obviously it doesn't have to include micro-detail, but the same boring colour everywhere would be 1. How much variety does the landscape have? How exciting is it?

 

Creativity

 

How creative was the file author? Is this map unique or could you find another one completely the same somewhere else? Does this map include things that others do not?

 

Reviews and comments do not get approved, all are publicly visible worldwide from the second you post. To do this it would require a lot of administrative time which we can ill-afford. StrongholdNation trusts the users to use the comment/review features appropriately. Failure of this may result in your ability to use them being removed. Please report any abusive posts to the site staff. StrongholdNation trusts the site staff to use their best judgment in assessing the intention of people who make such posts. If the staff member feels that any portion of a post is intended to be disruptive, insulting or generally inappropriate, they are empowered to remove or alter the post and in worst case, ban the poster.


Quote

The fields have eyes, and the woods have ears.

⁠— Geoffrey Chaucer, The Canterbury Tales: The Knight's Tale

Useful Articles

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Similar Topics

    • Download Section - Scenarios

      I have made a dozen scenarios earlier and had them published on another stronghold site. How do you feel about relaunching some of them here? I know they have to meet certain standards, but I'm confident that at least a handfull of them are, if not all. I've played (Stronghold and) Stronghold Crusader (SC) since release, but nowadays I find it more amusing to create content, than to play it. It's mainly to add more to the download section of StongholdNation, but also because I can't see myself d

      in Site Questions and Support

    • Download not approved

      I submitted a map for stronghold 1 ,looked fot it here and i get an error not found message,any thoughts? the file is called 'the divided kingdom'. I tried to resubmit it using version one of the file,but then i get 'file already exists'.

      in Site Questions and Support

    • Official Stronghold 2 suggestions list

      Use this thread to share and suggest ideas, new features or improvements for Stronghold 2. Ideas that collectively people agree or share I'll post in a list in this post. Starting with a few that I've seen or thought of already ....   AI in multiplayer Saving games in multiplayer Configurable autosave Seasons More Kingmaker/multiplayer settings such as: no rats, no gong, no crime, honour ... Auto market (like in Stronghold Legends) Better looking moats Custom crests in multiplayer games

      in Stronghold 2

    • Stronghold Crusader II, Review!

      The long awaited sequel was released today and as promised my review of the game is here. I hope this review will help you decide whether to buy the game or not, or if you'd just like something to read then here we go.   After playing the game for 3 hours, playing through the first 2 campaigns and starting the 3rd, also playing 2 matches of skirmish, this is what I have thought of the game so far.   First Impressions My first impression of the game automatically made me think of SH3. I thought t

      in Stronghold Crusader 2

    • The Official Strongholdnation PC is Here!

      It's time to unveil something pretty big. Lord_Chris and I got talking and we though it would be a great idea for those guys who are looking for a new PC if we released a Strongholdnation customised one. So I present to you, The Official Strongholdnation PC: (Apologies on the size of the images, they don't seem to be formatting correctly)   http://img.bitfenix.com/products_images/1059.png?1384496845[/img]http://img.bitfenix.com/products_images/1094.png?1384497224[/img]   [colour=red]For now, thi

      in The Town Crier

×
×
  • Create New...